Caution

Mandatory Arbitration

Disputes go to arbitration instead of court; venue, fees, and appeal grounds matter.

Show it
Look in the dispute resolution section for phrases like "mandatory arbitration", "binding arbitration", "shall be resolved by arbitration", "AAA", "JAMS", "ICC", or "jury trial waiver".
Decode it
Mandatory arbitration removes your right to courts, juries, and (typically) appeals. Arbitration is sometimes faster and cheaper than litigation - but mandatory arbitration forces you into that forum regardless of suitability. Where the venue is distant, fees are substantial, and appeal grounds are limited, the procedural cost of pursuing legitimate claims can exceed the dispute value.
Fix it
Push for: arbitration seated in a creator-convenient or neutral venue; shared filing and arbitrator fees; expedited rules for low-value disputes; small-claims court carve-out for very low value disputes; preserved appeal grounds on arbitrator error of law.

What it means

This contract requires disputes to be resolved through arbitration instead of court litigation. Arbitration is private dispute resolution conducted by an arbitrator (single or panel) under arbitration rules (AAA, JAMS, ICC). Mandatory arbitration removes your right to courts, juries, and (typically) appeals.

Mandatory arbitration means disputes go to a private arbitrator rather than a court, whether or not that suits the dispute. Where the arbitration venue is distant, fees are substantial, and appeal grounds are limited, the procedural cost of pursuing legitimate claims can exceed the dispute value. Combined with class-action waiver and one-way attorney fee shifting, mandatory arbitration can deter creator claims entirely.

What to check before you sign

  • ·What arbitration rules apply (AAA, JAMS, ICC, LCIA)?
  • ·Where is the arbitration seated?
  • ·What are the filing and arbitrator fees, and who pays?
  • ·Is there a class-action waiver?
  • ·Are appeals preserved on any grounds?
  • ·Are small-claims court remedies preserved for low-value disputes?
  • ·Is the arbitration mandatory for both parties or only the creator?

How to fix it

  • Arbitration seated in a creator-convenient location or in a neutral mutually-acceptable venue.

  • Arbitration filing and arbitrator fees shared between parties rather than imposed on the losing party or only on the creator.

  • Preserve small-claims court remedies for disputes below a defined value threshold.

  • Apply expedited arbitration rules for disputes below a defined value to ensure proceeding is proportionate.

Negotiating it

A good opening

"Could we add three things to the arbitration clause: a neutral venue, shared filing and arbitrator fees, and a small-claims court carve-out? "

When to walk away

Mandatory arbitration in distant jurisdiction, creator-pays fee structure, no small-claims carve-out, class-action waiver, no appeal grounds, combined with broad indemnity, uncapped liability, is a strong walk-away signal. The creator faces procedural costs that exceed most dispute values while also bearing substantive risk.

Find this clause in your own contract.

Scan your brand deal free - 2 contract scans, no card required.

Scan your contract free →

Related clauses

Educational guidance, not legal advice. For high-value or complex deals, get independent legal advice from a qualified professional.