High risk

Clawback Rights on Paid Fees

The contract lets the brand recover fees you have already been paid under defined triggers.

Show it
Look in the payment, termination, breach, or remedies section for phrases like "clawback", "recoup", "refund of fees", "repay", "return all amounts", "set off", or "reimburse the brand". Section headings like "Repayment", "Recovery", or "Set-off" often signal a clawback structure.
Decode it
Clawback rights convert received payment back into conditional payment. By the time a clawback is triggered you may already have paid tax on the income, spent it on production costs, or treated it as firm revenue. The severity of the clause depends on three things: how specifically the triggers are defined, whether the recoverable amount is capped, and how long the window stays open. Broad subjective triggers with no cap and no sunset are the worst combination.
Fix it
Negotiate on three axes in parallel: narrow the triggers to specific objective events with notice-and-cure mechanics, cap the recoverable amount (typically 25-50% of fees paid, or fees minus production costs), and time-box the window (commonly 6-12 months from engagement end). Any one of the three is a meaningful improvement.

What it means

This contract gives the brand the right to take back money you have already been paid. The triggers vary, the content being removed, performance falling short of agreed targets, a breach of conduct or morality rules, reputational issues, or termination, but the practical effect is the same: the fees you received are not yours to keep with confidence until the clawback window has closed.

A clawback turns received payment into conditional payment. By the time a clawback is triggered, you may already have paid tax on the income, spent it on production costs, or treated it as firm revenue for personal or business planning. Where the trigger is broad or subjective, "reputational harm", "the brand's reasonable judgement", "any breach", the financial exposure can sit open for months or years. The clause becomes materially worse when paired with a no-kill-fee or fee-contingency clause: the payment is both contingent at the front end and recoverable at the back end.

What to check before you sign

  • ·What specific events trigger the clawback? Are they objective (verifiable facts) or subjective (brand judgement)?
  • ·Is the clawback window time-limited (e.g., 6 months) or open-ended?
  • ·Is the recoverable amount capped, or is the full fee recoverable?
  • ·Are already-incurred production costs excluded from recovery?
  • ·Does the clause require notice and an opportunity to cure before clawback is triggered?
  • ·Is the clawback connected to a morality clause or KPI shortfall, and how is the threshold defined?

How to fix it

  • moderate

    Replace open-ended or subjective triggers with a closed list of specific objective events (e.g., proven failure to deliver, content removal by creator within 30 days, documented material breach with notice and cure).

  • moderate

    Add a cap on the recoverable amount, typically expressed as a percentage of fees paid (25-50%) or as fees received minus documented production costs.

  • easy

    Limit the clawback window to a defined period after engagement end (commonly 6-12 months), after which the fees are unconditionally final.

  • moderate

    Require the brand to provide written notice of the clawback trigger and a defined cure period before recovery rights crystallise.

  • harder

    Where the clawback is KPI-linked, exclude factors outside the creator's reasonable control (platform algorithm changes, third-party events, brand-side amendments to the campaign).

Negotiating it

A good opening

"I'd like to understand the clawback clause better. The triggers as drafted are quite broad; could we agree on a closed list of specific events, a cap on the recoverable amount, and a defined post-engagement window? "

When to walk away

Broad subjective triggers (any reputational harm, brand's reasonable judgement, any breach) combined with no time limit, no cap, and no notice-and-cure mechanic, and paired with no_kill_fee or fee_contingency, is a strong walk-away signal. The clause structure leaves the creator's revenue permanently conditional on the brand's discretion.

Find this clause in your own contract.

Scan your brand deal free - 2 contract scans, no card required.

Scan your contract free →

Related clauses

Educational guidance, not legal advice. For high-value or complex deals, consult a qualified solicitor.